A Progressive Foreign Policy Agenda for Congress from CIP Advocacy

Today, CIP Advocacy shared a legislative agenda to the offices of legislators on Capitol Hill. The program builds on policies and research from the Center for International Policy, drawing from Executive Vice President Matt Duss’s call for a foreign policy revolution, published this month in Foreign Affairs.

The three-pronged agenda is built around stopping endless wars, defeating corruption at home and abroad, and reducing the cost of living.

“The new majority in the coming Congress can advance an ambitious foreign policy agenda around the three concerns voters made clear in the midterm election: endless wars, unprecedented corruption, and the rising cost of living,” writes Vice President of Government Affairs Dylan Williams writes. “The three are deeply linked, with Americans viscerally aware that the most severe threats to their security and livelihoods now come from within: a president who launches unauthorized wars while enriching his family and cronies, and an economy increasingly dominated by a handful of oligarchs and corporations threatening to destroy their jobs and financial futures.”

Explore the full agenda below:

Author & Attribution Notice: This policy memorandum was researched, drafted, and published by Center for International Policy Advocacy, an independent 501(c)(4) social welfare organization. It is shared on the CIP website for educational and informational purposes only. The views, legislative recommendations, and policy positions expressed in this document are solely those of Center for International Policy Advocacy.


The Nvidia Scandal Is Not a Spy Thriller — It’s Corruption

Corrupt bargains have fueled Nvidia’s terrifying hold over the US economy. Revelations that its CEO is allegedly dating a Chinese spy shouldn’t distract Congress from the corruption powering Nvidia and the AI sector. It’s time for accountability and firm government regulation.

The story of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, his confessed affair with an executive at data center company Megaspeed, and her reported ties to China’s intelligence services read like a spy thriller, a serviceable plot for an airport paperback for business travelers. Already, hawks are seizing upon the affair to launch protectionist and national security arguments against trade and exchange between the world’s two largest economies. But this framing is misleading. The Nvidia scandal is fundamentally a corruption problem, with suspicious deals that include foreign interests and also implicate deals between the Trump administration and Nvidia, which appear to violate existing rules and dodge congressional oversight. 

The newly elected Congress should use hearings to expose the web of influence peddling that allowed one component supplier to achieve and sustain market domination. Congress should go further: regulation is needed to not just defend against compromise, but to ensure such corporate power cannot be concentrated in single individuals, away from public accountability.

The stakes could not be higher. Modern life exists in the shadow of data centers, the massive warehouses for processors that form the physical, electrical pulse of the AI industry. In those centers data is ingested, restructured, and rendered into new products fueling the latest massive growth of the technology industry, which in turn touches the rest of the economy wherever it meets the internet. Inside these data centers are processors, the largest share of which are made by Nvidia. The scale, power, and concentrated wealth inherent in the AI giants, and in the development and selling of hardware on which their models run, is such a scale that reports of infidelity among its CEO can cause $100s of billions in market cap to evaporate. 

Industry and Security

On November 8, Nvidia’s board began an investigation into the relationship between CEO Jensen Huang and Alice Huang (no relation), a former television reporter turned executive at Megaspeed, a data center company, whom the US Intelligence community believes to be a Chinese spy. 

The New York Times reports that the Commerce Department was months into an investigation of Megaspeed for smuggling Nvidia processors into China until the investigation was abruptly transferred to the Justice Department in 2025, after the Commerce investigators received a message from Nvidia’s general counsel saying that Jeff Kessler, Under Secretary of Commerce for Industry and Security, had given Nvidia permission to reach out concerning the case.

“Perhaps inadvertently,” officials told the New York Times, the Trump-appointed Kessler, “had opened himself to accusations of undue influence and potentially jeopardized his department’s work on Megaspeed.”

Under the first Trump and the Biden administration, Commerce’s Bureau of Industry and Security expanded export controls on semiconductor technologies to China, designed to ensure that powerful processors like those made by Nvidia do not end up used for “activities contrary to U.S. national security or foreign policy interests.” In the last days of the Biden administration, the Bureau issued a new AI Diffusion Rule, meant to keep China from acquiring the most advanced processors and AI computing power, part of a broader effort to build a separate bloc of AI partner countries.

The Trump administration, notes the Congressional Research Service, both “tightened and loosened export controls on chips,” blocking many entities from legal export while creating pathways for other exports. Nvidia responded to the Biden and Trump era rules by developing modified chips for export to China, with reduced capacity to comply with regulation for export.

In August 2025, at the same time that Nvidia’s general counsel reached out to the Commerce investigators, the Bureau of Industry and Security approved modified Nvidia processors for export to China, an approval that came after CEO Jensen Huang met with Trump. The deal, the Financial Times reported two days later, included an agreement where Nvidia agreed to “give the US government 15 per cent of the revenues from chip sales in China.”

When voters elected a new Congress on November 3rd, they sent them to Washington with an anti-corruption mandate. CIP Fellow Casey Michel writes, corruption “is now at the heart of American politics, and even the American economy.”

Market Functions

Nvidia was valued at nearly $6 trillion at the start of October. Reporting on Jensen’s affair sparked a 9.87 percent decline in the stock from price at close on Friday through Tuesday afternoon, a market cap drop of $444.4 billion on the news. It is likely that as further investigations come forward, the processor giant may fare worse. The exact fluctuations of the industry are less significant than the sheer scale at which these tech giants operate, behemoths of capital whose gravitational pull bends the actions of large governments and overpowers small ones.

Nvidia, as the pulsing hardware heart of the AI boom, has a distorting effect on the entire industry so powerful that it functions as its own bank, guiding the AI industry through favorable investments and guarantees. These investments nurture and proliferate a field of AI providers that help challenge dominant giants like Microsoft and Google that present account for much of Nvidia’s revenue, but are investing in their own dedicated AI chips custom-built, rather than adapted, to the task. This is industrial policy guided by industry to serve industry, and it is particularly closely guided. The New York Times reports that CEO Huang “set up a unique structure at Nvidia where he dictates all aspects of its business while overseeing some 60 people who directly report to him.”

All of that makes Huang a potential single point of compromise, and one with outsized implications for AI development narrowly, and for industrial (and national) competition between the United States and China broadly. That Commerce was already investigating Megaspeed’s relation to China and US export control laws proves a solid foundation for Congressionally authorized investigation. The timing of Huang’s meeting with Trump, and of Kessler’s correspondence with Nvidia concerning both the investigation and the export licensure, is worth further exploration.

Investigators will determine (unless Trump tries to interfere) if the deals Huang struck were compromised by the adversarial interests of a foreign government, a business imperative by seeking to maximize capital, or a case of cronyism buying favor with Trump to mutually beneficial ends. Corruption investigations, initiated by Congress and guaranteed independence, can determine the specifics of if, where, how, and why existing US rules over technology export were violated. Already, the House Foreign Affairs Committee has requested Huang appear at a hearing on November 18th, when Trump expects him to be present at the APEC conference in Shenzen. Senators Jim Banks and Elizabeth Warren, meanwhile, took the opportunity to encourage the passage of the AI OVERWATCH Act, which seeks to ensure American-produced processing power for the United States while keeping it from China.

Operationalizing Oversight 

The next Congress can go beyond the narrow scope of a hearing on China infiltrating the US to gain access to cutting-edge U.S. technology. If a single CEO getting swooned by a foreign intelligence service is a point of failure for the entire technology sector and most of the growth in the US economy, it is technology that is long overdue for real regulatory oversight and control, beyond the discretionary rules of agencies that can be waived off for a cut of the profit.

As Ari Tolany and I wrote in A World For All, existing actors, networks, and institutions, “are legally, politically, and epistemically ill-equipped to grapple with the role of AI in the international system.” Yet like other technologies whose industrial champions heralded them as world-changing, we can build modern AI policy that starts “by treating AI as a tool, like electricity, that is bound by the laws of both physics and states.” And like other gilded ages dominated by rampant, disruptive, self-dealing industries, the way forward is to transform an easily compromised hoard of wealth and capacity into a mundane, human-regulated industry, where the consequences of indiscretion risk neither national security nor the pensions of retirees.

While national security concerns dominate existing regulations about export control and AI capability, the case of Huang and Nvidia is at least as much a story about transnational capital buying its way around rules, with competing elites vying for control over finite commodities and processing power. Addressing only the national security side of the corruption still leaves in place tremendous wealth and capacity held narrowly, entrenching competing sets of elites bound by nations and just as able to buy their way around unfavorable rules. Asserting democratic sovereignty over the potential and harms of the industry means treating it like any other, while adapting instruments, such as dedicated independent oversight, powered by civil servants with specialized knowledge and the autonomy to act in the public interest.

It is well and good for future investigations in Huang, Nvidia, Kessler, and Trump to center on violations of standing law, as well as potential compromises of sensitive information. But the story of Nvidia and Megaspeed is less the story of one country stealing from another, and more a story about how the power and incentives of capital encourage payment for regulatory bypass instead of compliance with law. When the new Congress is seated in January, it should work to build a regulatory regime for AI that sees the risk as not originating solely from foreign governments, but from powerful technology controlled by the very few, with proprietary secrets so important they required export control, and so easily compromised they can be obtained over a few drinks in Taipei.

Kelsey D. Atherton is the Chief Editor at the Center for International Policy.

This story is an expansion on themes explored in A World For All.


Here’s How Congress Should Fight Corruption

After the midterm elections, Democrats should prioritize anti-corruption investigations. They can start with the Trump family, argues Casey Michel.

Two years into Donald Trump’s second administration, corruption is undeniably the defining issue of our time. Amidst unprecedented kleptocracy, overseen by an administration dedicated to brazen self-enrichment, Trump’s second term catapulted concerns about corruption to their greatest relevance in decades. While Trump at one point claimed that few people cared about his or his administration’s corruption, the recent midterms have proven him spectacularly wrong. Not only was corruption one of the clearest motivators for voters this week, but it was perhaps the most important topic—arguably for the first time in American electoral history. 

This new Congress has a clear mandate. It must transform voters’ concerns about corruption into momentum and progress. None of this will be easy, nor will all of the solutions be legislative alone. Trump has two more years in the White House – and opportunities not to just continue enriching himself and his family, but to block any kind of legislative solutions to rebuilding America’s anti-corruption architecture. 

White House opposition can’t stop the new Congress from placing corruption at the core of all of its efforts over the next two years. There must be high-level hearings, including a broad swath of subpoenas, on the spectacular corruption scandals we’ve seen this term, from the Trump family’s profiteering to his transformation of the pardons process into an open-air bidding racket, to launching an examination of how the most oligarchic forces and wealthiest corporations used campaign finance loopholes buy favorable outcomes. At the heart of all of this must be showing how all of this corruption harmed the average American, and how it decimated the American economy, and how it warped American foreign policy in the process. Along the way, policy-makers must begin building out a 2028 campaign playbook to continue this anti-corruption momentum, preventing not only brazen Trumpian corruption from returning but ending the decades-long policies, trends, and loopholes that led to a figure like Trump, and all of this corruption, in the first place.  

Voters Sick of Corruption

American voters told pollster after pollster that they are voting against corruption. Opposition to corruption transcends partisan lines; in an October 2026 poll, Fox News revealed that corruption topped the list of voter concerns in the midterms, surpassing everything from inflation to the war in Iran and beyond. 

Ten years since Donald Trump was first elected, his two administrations have overseen far and away the most kleptocratic regimes the U.S. has ever seen. Crypto schemes alone brought in over a billion dollars to the president and his family. Private investments flowed from foreign regimes to Jared Kushner, like an invisible hand on the scale helping Kushner guide his father-in-law’s policies from Iran to Israel to Ukraine and beyond. There are the real estate investments, the procurement scandals, and pay-to-play schemes for everything from pardons to sanctions relief and beyond. The list runs on ad nauseum.  

Trump may be a singularly corrupt figure in the history of the American presidency, but he benefits from years of increasingly favorable climates for corruption, like a Supreme Court that gutted campaign finance laws while legalizing bribery, to a compliant Congress that repeatedly shied away from taxing the wealthy.

After two years of the second Trump administration, the price and visibility of corruption is inescapeable. And, as voters demonstrated on Tuesday, Americans are desperate for anti-corruption in action, not just rhetoric. 

Which is why it’s now – right now, and not later – that a future Democratic Congress, and any campaign to retake the White House, prepares an accountability agenda to end this morass of corruption,  bringing this Age of Oligarchy to a close. The Center for International Policy contribution to that effort is our anti-corruption initiative, The Unrigging Project: Ending the Age of Impunity.

Targets for investigation 

Thankfully, Congress doesn’t necessarily need to pass legislation to be effective, at least after the midterms. With the majority, Democratic lawmakers can – and must – press ahead with high-level investigations into everything from the Trump family’s self-enrichment to the broader ways that American policy, both domestic and foreign, has been sold to the highest bidders. Once the new majority is seated, Democrats can once more use subpoena powers to force information out of investigative targets – and begin revealing how this American kleptocracy has impacted voters across the country. 

The most pertinent precedent remains the post-Watergate hearings led by Sen. Frank Church, who steered a select committee into intelligence abuses – and uncovered a raft of corruption scandals along the way. A select committee, in both the House and Senate, remains a nimble, dedicated option for leading these kinds of investigations. 

Such investigations don’t need to be limited to specific committees. If anything, breaking up the investigations into simultaneous topics and tracks can allow the new Congressional majority to tackle more (though not necessarily all) of the topics at hand – and craft a narrative about how all of this corruption has impacted the broad swath of Americans. 

Congressional investigations after the midterms should start with three major subjects: the Trump family, pardons and prosecutions, and money in politics.

Investigating the Trump family – and especially the children: Despite a reputation as being immune to corruption allegations, the staggering levels of self-enrichment embodied in Trump during his second term has notably dented his support. His children and in-laws – Donald Trump Jr., Eric Trump, Jared Kushner, and more – were never elected, and have no constituencies of their own. They present significant openings for Democrats to investigate the levels of self-dealing and rank corruption swirling through the administration. Defense procurement, crypto, foreign entanglements, the impact on everything from domestic policy to national security – investigating the Trump family and its hangers-on presents abundant  opportunities for Democrats to shine a light on just how much the administration is dedicated to personal profiteering at the expense of American interests. 

Pardons and dropped prosecutions: While there have always been questions about the scope and allowances for presidential pardons, we have never seen the kind of open-air market that has developed for bidding for pardons from President Trump. Story after story have revealed the details of an entire infrastructure of these kinds of pay-for-pardon schemes, now running into the millions of dollars with a proliferation of lobbyists and fixers acting as middlemen. Nor, of course, are those seeking these indulgent pardons among those actually deserving of them. Among those pardoned thus far are notorious scammers, fraudsters, and money launderers who targeted prone victims – the kind of white-collar criminals that Trump would recognize. So too are those foreign nationals who have either been pardoned or seen prosecutions explicitly blocked, from Trump’s pardon of Juan Orlando Hernández, the former Honduran president convicted of drug trafficking, to the Justice Department’s abandonment of prosecution against Gautam Adani, the  wealthy Indian oligarch accused of both fraud and bribery. Such investigations into this open-air market for pardons can shine a light on how it is only the wealthiest, and the most criminal, who have obtained them – and how it has all forced their victims to suffer once more. 

The explosion of money in politics: The intertwining of money and politics reached a natural end-state under Trump, in which the deepest-pocketed donors, either oligarchic or corporate, often buy their way and their preferred policies, regardless of what Americans want. Trump has made no secret of the open-door relationships his administration has developed with its constellation of donors. Nor are these just companies and corporate heads taking advantage of the lack of campaign finance regulations. Everything from the White House ballroom to Trump’s future library has been saturated by the wealthiest donors – many of whom promptly get their way, and whatever they want, from the administration. A congressional investigation centering and exposing all of these networks not only presents the opportunity to illustrate how little American interests play a role in administration decisions – but also lays the groundwork for far more substantial anti-corruption and campaign finance reform moving forward. 

These three targets present an opportunity for Democrats to highlight the kind of elite impunity that predates Trump, and that is inextricable from anti-corruption reforms more broadly. They craft a story that centers victims, and showcase the true costs of corruption for everyday Americans. 

They will also set the stage for plans for 2028 campaigns – and beyond. 

Looking ahead to 2028: Rebuild the Architecture

Fighting corruption should remain one of the primary pillars of Democratic campaigns after the midterms, including as candidates begin building out their 2028 playbooks. There are a number of reforms that they must focus on, falling into three primary buckets. 

Trump used his second term to destroy much of the anti-corruption architecture that the US  developed over decades. He’s succeeded far more than anticipated – but only to a point. While Trump spent much of his second administration detonating the US’s anti-corruption tools, he and his allies have not managed to repeal related legislation – meaning that, should a Democrat retake the White House, they will have every opportunity on their first day in office to restore all of the programs and policies Trump poleaxed. 

This is true across the executive branch. Out of the Treasury and Justice Departments, a new Democratic president can instantly restore the previous task forces dedicated to targeting networks of both domestic and international corruption. So too can a future president restore related bodies within the International Revenue Service to specifically target the wealthiest tax cheats in the U.S. And the next administration can announce the immediate reinforcement of tools like the US’s shell company registry, as well as things like the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA). The foundation is, despite all of Trump’s efforts, still there – it just needs to be rebuilt. 

But a future administration can’t simply rebuild—they must also restore, and even expand, the funding for all of this. Funding for things like the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), the IRS, the DOJ’s Public Integrity office, the Federal Election Commission, and other bodies (including more detailed below) related to corruption in America must be expanded. As we have seen, absent funding, these bodies can and will atrophy – and corruption will flourish as a result. 

Broaden the policy

The next president cannot stop there. It’s not enough to simply restore America’s anti-corruption architecture to what it was; it must be expanded, and significantly. 

This must start with traditional means of money laundering and corruption. A future administration, alongside allies in Congress, must immediately  close anti-money laundering loopholes for industries like real estate, private equity, hedge funds, and venture capital. These loopholes first emerged in the mid-2000s, and allowed all of these industries to explode into destinations for dirty money – including from foreign sources. 

But it’s not just traditional sources. In recent years, industries like crypto have likewise exploded as go-to money laundering vehicles, allowing for the immediate transfer and transformation of illicit wealth around the world to be moved, hidden, and injected into the American economy – including into American politics. For too long, crypto enthusiasts have claimed that they can and should be the ones overseeing all kinds of anti-corruption checks in their industry. But they have failed, spectacularly. This entire industry, most especially those who oversee the mixing of cryptocurrencies and those interacting with unhosted wallets, must be subject to stringent anti-money laundering requirements. 

So, too, must there be new regulations on the so-called “enablers” who provide everything from accounting and legal services to structuring these offshore and laundering networks in the first place. This is especially true for law firms, who have been caught out providing everything from shell company formation to lobbying services for nefarious actors for years, pointing to specific legal loopholes as reason enough not to conduct basic anti-corruption checks. This class of middlemen provides the expertise, guidance, and protections that networks both foreign and domestic rely on to hide their money from investigators around the world – and to curry favors with American politicians, buying them off and purchasing American policy in the process. 

In addition to all of these new anti-money laundering requirements, Congress must spearhead a new push to broaden transparency requirements elsewhere. This is especially true for two vehicles in particular: shell companies and trusts. For decades, these two vehicles have provided all of the secrecy and legal protections that corrupt networks both near and far require to hide their wealth. However, they have long abused those secrecy protections, transforming into key threats to American democracy in the process. While they shouldn’t be banned outright, the U.S. must pass legislation requiring their public registration, and identifying who are their ultimate owners or beneficiaries. If these vehicles want to continue enjoying legal protections, the least their owners can do is provide details on their structure and who benefits – and, it goes without saying, how they may connect to any American policy-makers or campaign funders in the process. 

Expand the toolkit

The executive, along with congressional allies, must also expand the fight against corruption. Significant transparency requirements, and even restrictions, must be placed on presidential pardons, allowing far greater insight into how and why a president issues a pardon – and what kind of payments were involved. Broader reforms within the executive branch must restore the independence of the Justice Department, preventing future executives from pursuing or dropping prosecutions and investigations in the name of political considerations. Congress should even consider revisiting previous authorities it had to appoint special counsels dedicated solely to anti-corruption offices, akin to what other countries like Albania have formed, tasked with overseeing major anti-corruption investigations. And the executive must pursue all options available – including to the point of supporting a constitutional amendment – to overturn the Supreme Court’s recent rulings allowing both unbridled campaign finance regulations and the breathtakingly strict definitions surrounding what counts as bribery. 

Nor can policy-makers stop there. Reformers must specifically target the Supreme Court for anti-corruption reform as well, implementing everything from transparency requirements for justices’ sources of funding to limits on court terms. Reformers must also place an outright ban on all stock-trading for members of the legislative, judicial, and executive branches, including Cabinet-level officials. And further strict bans must be placed on any official engaging in any prediction markets, which have opened up a brand new space for further insider trading and related corruption, without any requisite guardrails. Such bans should also be considered for any family members of any officials as well. 

Coordinate Efforts

Much of this will take time, and will significantly broaden the aperture of America’s anti-corruption efforts. As such, the executive must introduce a new body tasked with overseeing all facets of anti-corruption coordination. 

We have already begun seeing indications of this, as with Sen. Schumer’s formal call for an anti-corruption bureau. Similar efforts have proven effective elsewhere, like Ukraine’s National Anti-Corruption Bureau. In order to streamline and successfully expand anti-corruption policies and efforts – including investigations, policy proposals, funding, enforcement, and more – the executive should introduce the US’s own Anti-Corruption Bureau, acting as a clearinghouse and coordinator for everything from Treasury, State, Justice, the FBI, CIA, and more. 

With this new body, America’s ad hoc anti-corruption efforts can find far more organization and for more efficacy – and continue the momentum already building far more effectively. Absent greater coordination, these efforts risk disintegrating, and setting anti-corruption work back years. As detailed below, this new body can also act as a broader center for linking anti-corruption efforts with campaign finance reform and tax policy, all of which remain the primary prongs for restoring American democracy more broadly. It can also act as a center of efforts to liaise with state-level corruption investigations and attorneys general, serving as a great means of coordinating anti-corruption efforts at multiple levels of government in the U.S. 

Likewise, as detailed in the next section, this new bureau can serve as the center for international anti-corruption efforts as well. Rather than dealing with scattered investigators and policy-makers, America’s democratic partners elsewhere will have a new body dedicated to aligning anti-corruption interests – and expanding this burst of anti-corruption momentum beyond the U.S. itself. 

Anti-corruption in America, anti-corruption internationally

Corruption, as the Biden administration previously outlined, is a core national security threat, and it can be beaten by Democracy, just as the Confederacy was in the 19th century and totalitarianism was in the 20th century. The fight against corruption is the 21st century’s fight for democracy. 

All of those reforms must center accountability. Americans correctly understand that impunity protects the elites steering  American politics, American economics, and American lives. Whether launching the Iraq War, driving the Great Recession, or aiding and abetting the genocidal war in Gaza, entire generations of elites – many of whom have been caught up in their own networks of corruption – skated off without any accountability whatsoever. That must change, both for the sake of the success of corruption reforms and for the future of American democracy writ large. Accountability must be a core, constituent part of the congressional investigations mentioned above, as well as the plans for executive-level reforms post-2028. 

This elite impunity extends to not just Americans guiding foreign policy, but often their allies, like the Bolsonaros, who sought to return Brazil to a crony state and were welcomed into the United States after electoral defeats, where they can avoid legal consequences at home.

The future of anti-corruption policy must adapt to the ways corruption evolved to evade old safeguards. In the 21st century, corruption is a far broader phenomenon than past, narrow definitions, as Americans well recognize. It’s no longer just about bags of cash slid under tables, or backroom dealings that benefit both public and private parties (especially since the Supreme Court ruled payment for favors already rendered doesn’t count). Corruption is now at the heart of American politics, and even the American economy. 

Modern anti-corruption includes ending the practices of offshore wealth and tax havenry more broadly. Shell companies, tax-dodging schemes, multinational races to the bottom – these are all prongs of corruption, and should be understood as such. They bilk taxpayers, gut nations, and lead directly to the rise of the kinds of oligarchy now dominating both democracies and dictatorships alike. 

Anti-corruption work must also extend to: campaign finance. While much of America’s campaign finance architecture remains perfectly legal – and therefore not traditionally understood as corruption, per se – the stark majority of Americans recognize for exactly what it is: the selling-off of American policy to those who can bankroll politicians, rather than constituents and voters. “Legalized corruption” may be an oxymoron, but it is the current state of American politics – which is why, to ensure the future success of anti-corruption efforts, campaign finance reform must be at the center of discussions. Indeed, it’s long past time to recognize that the fight for fairer taxation, the fight for campaign finance reform, and the fight for anti-offshore reforms are all part of the same struggle – and part of the anti-corruption conversation. 

None of this will be easy. But we know what needs to be done. Now we simply have to be ready.   

On Tuesday, voters gave Congress a mandate that they’re ready for action on corruption. Now, they are waiting for their new leaders to deliver the promise of a less corrupt present, and a far less corrupt future. 

Casey Michel is a Senior Non Resident Fellow at the Center for International Policy.

This report is part of the Center for International Policy’s anti-corruption initiative, The Unrigging Project: Ending the Age of Impunity. 


Foreign Policy at the Fore in A Change Election

Foreign policy might not be the first concern of every voter, but it’s top of mind for most in a time of war, American authoritarianism, and economic crisis. Center for International Policy experts on the international policy stakes of the US midterm elections.

Many candidates in the US midterm elections on November 3 have framed the election as an existential referendum on American democracy. Will voters reject the authoritarian practices of President Donald J. Trump? Foreign policy is at the front and center of the election, with a generational shift on the table. Twenty-five years since the Sept. 11 attacks, two generations of the American electorate – and the political class – have been shaped by world-changing American wars of choice. 

Narrowly, voters are choosing members of the U.S. House and Senate, as well as many state and local legislators and officials. Broadly, however, voters are expressing their preferences between war and peace, democracy and authoritarianism, chauvinism and cooperation. Americans are suffer a cost-of-living crisis brought on by an entirely elective US war against Iran — even while the US and Israel continue a genocide in Gaza and ethnic cleansing in the West Bank and Lebanon. Foreign policy might not be the first concern of every voter, but it’s top of mind for most.

To better understand how the election will shape US foreign policy, and what changes may reverberate throughout the world, experts from the Center for International Policy highlight the stakes for critical international issues in a world in flux.

Compiled and edited by Kelsey D. Atherton.

Extreme Corruption Prompts Backlash

Casey Michel

It’s clear that voters cared more about corruption in this election cycle than at any point in living memory—and maybe ever in American history. But the anti-corruption energy won’t end here. Voters expect high-level investigations into everything from the Trump family’s corruption to the pay-to-play nature of pardons to how American policy was consistently sold to the highest bidder, leading to disasters both domestic and foreign. And they’re expecting something else: accountability. For too long, elite accountability has been the name of the game in Washington—and has led directly to all of this rank corruption, of which voters are sick and tired. 

Democrats have an unprecedented opportunity to expose all of the corruption rotting Washington, and to set the stage for an even bigger anti-corruption campaign in 2028. It’s an opportunity they won’t get again—and that they can’t afford to squander. 

Iran Deal or No Deal

Sina Toosi

What I’m watching most closely in the midterms is how the outcome shapes Trump’s calculations about another major escalation with Iran. With reports that Washington is preparing for possible renewed military operations immediately after the election, the stakes could hardly be higher.

A major Republican defeat would leave Trump politically weakened, facing greater congressional scrutiny and probably leave him more concerned about salvaging his presidency and legacy. That could strengthen incentives for diplomacy, particularly given Iran’s demonstrated ability to disrupt global energy markets through its leverage over Hormuz. This is as another major escalation, especially one targeting regional energy infrastructure, could trigger an economic crisis with devastating political consequences for Trump.

Yet a weakened president with little left to lose electorally might also be more inclined to gamble on military force in pursuit of a decisive victory.

The central question is whether the midterm results make Trump more cautious or more willing to take more extraordinary risks. No longer facing another election himself, his calculations will presumably be shaped by his legacy and what he hopes to achieve in the final two years of his presidency.

Rejecting Forever Wars Abroad and at Home

Yumna Rizvi

What gets built for war abroad always comes back home. Tuesday will show whether Congress is ready to face that. 

The so-called Global War on Terror wrote a playbook: indefinite detention, torture, secret legal memos, expansive war authorities, impunity, and a label that can be stretched to fit anyone. No one was held accountable, so the playbook keeps getting reused: in the war on Iran, strikes in the Caribbean and Eastern Pacific that Congress never authorized, and at home in immigration enforcement, policing, and detention. Military-grade equipment continues to flow to local police through programs like 1033 and 1122. Taxpayers pay twice: once for the war, and again for the machinery built to police them.

I’m looking for a Congress that won’t stop at ending forever wars: one that reclaims its war powers, follows the money, and asks who profits and who is targeted. Restraint abroad and accountability at home are how the playbook finally ends. 

A Middle East Policy Not Centered on Israel

Sam Heller

In terms of my main area of focus, Lebanon and Syria, neither country has really featured in any midterm race.

Israel and AIPAC, though, have figured prominently in a number of races—Michigan, most notably. If Abdul El-Sayed and other Israel-critical candidates win, that would represent a major blow to pro-Israel groups’ influence domestically. That, in turn, would raise new questions about the future of U.S. support for Israel.

Support for Israel is, to a large extent, the organizing principle of U.S. policy in the Middle East. If that support—heretofore unconditional, effectively—is no longer dependable and constant, then the logic of U.S. involvement in the region begins to de-cohere. That could open up all kinds of new policy possibilities, including reconsideration of the United States’ relationships with its regional authoritarian partners and—fingers crossed—an end to U.S. backing for continued Israeli aggression against Lebanon and Syria.

Voters Tired of War

Allie Hansen

Now that the anti-war veneer that put Donald Trump into office is gone, voters are looking to new candidates – the midterms could very well bring the largest cohort of progressive lawmakers to Capitol Hill.

Since Trump’s illegal war on Iran started, the executive branch has notified congress of almost $80 billion in major Foreign Military Sales of arms to the Israeli government and countries in the Gulf, and congress has given little oversight. Voters are feeling the effects of the war on their daily lives: over half of Americans in a recent poll believe that ending the war would improve the cost of living by “a lot.” After midterms, Congress should take their role seriously – they have the opportunity to enforce existing law, question arms sales that do not benefit the American people, and block defense spending that will continue the illegal war in Iran.

To follow through on their commitments to Americans after midterms, it is time for Democrats to expel the corrupt myth that sending billions of dollars of weapons to human rights abusers is protecting Americans. It is robbing them of funds that should be put into healthcare, public schools, and feeding and housing American families.

Tax War Profiteers to Offset Accumulating Costs

Zachary Cuyler

Pundits use gas prices as a bellwether for U.S. electoral politics. In the context of the Iran war, commentators assume that the Strait of Hormuz works like a tap, and that the United States and Iran are fighting over the rate of flow to determine the price of gasoline and shape the midterms. 

But the war’s effects are cumulative. Even as more oil has started to flow, the cost of moving it has increased. Accumulating damage to refineries in the Middle East (and Russia) has durably raised the price of diesel. High diesel prices hit rural voters dependent on trucking and agriculture hardest, but also raise the price of anything moved by truck or rail–virtually everything Americans consume. Even if the war somehow ends tomorrow, elected officials will have to deal with its long-term consequences. They should look to oil companies’ massive wartime profits when they do.

Rejecting War, Rejecting Islamophobia

Negar Mortazavi

As an Iran expert, I’m watching whether Trump’s war on Iran becomes a defining political liability for Republicans in this election.

Trump campaigned against endless U.S. wars in the Middle East and won votes promising to avoid them. Instead, alongside Netanyahu, he launched two illegal wars of aggression against Iran in 2025 and 2026, costing American blood and treasure and driving up prices for American families.

If Republicans lose, it will send a powerful warning to future presidents: starting another costly, open-ended war in the Middle East carries a political price at home.

I’m also watching Abdul El-Sayed’s Senate race in Michigan. This contest represents a front line in the struggle of Muslim Americans against racism, Islamophobia, xenophobia, and other forms of prejudice that often intensify when the U.S. wages wars in the Middle East. It will be an important test of whether Americans reject these politics of fear and division.

The Oligarchy Loses Steam

Nancy Okail

Already we have seen candidates who are mainly outside the establishment win primaries despite billionaire’s attempts to bury them with money. At the same time, candidates like Abdul El-Sayed and Adam Hamawy endure racist attacks, ones deemed acceptable in political and media circles. Triumph despite billionaire-backed attacks comes from voters rejecting the conduct of those opposed to pluralistic democracy.

Constituents have made clear their opposition to U.S. involvement in war, whose costs they bear while military contractors profit. Congress must use its constitutional powers to enforce the law, end the war, and cut further funding. It should hold hearings, investigative war profiteering, and hold those responsible accountable. Congress should also take this as an opportunity to reconsider its support of Israel, to stop abetting the genocide in Gaza and the illegal settlement of the West Bank.

The electoral turn is a challenge to increasingly unchecked oligarchic power. Tech billionaires spent a decade shaping policies to their own profit. Candidates across the nation campaigned against such corruption. We are looking to see a Congress meet the charge from the voters that elected them, and govern on anti-corruption to confront, restoring power to democracy and away from oligarchy.

End of the Blob

Thanassis Cambanis

For generations, a small coterie has held sway over US foreign policy, embracing a bipartisan consensus based on the flawed notion that war and military domination can secure American interests.

Status quo thinking has proved disastrous for America and the rest of the world. Since the US invasion of Iraq in 2003, Washington has led an assault on international law, multilateral institutions, and what remained of the Geneva Conventions. 

Advisers to Barack Obama rightly derided “the blob,” foreign policy experts who got all the major decisions wrong but somehow maintained a stranglehold on policymaking, even when it was clear to normie, non-expert, voters that those policies were epochal failures. Many of those same advisers went on to start new wars and underwrite the genocide in Gaza, and set the stage for Trump’s illegal and unwarranted war on Iran.

The good news is that candidates and voters are breaking the blob’s shackles. They don’t want a foreign policy imposed on them which savages the world and leaves Americans worse off too. The blob’s consensus left no one safer or better off. The raw and open discourse about Gaza, Israel, the Iran war, and America’s destructive addiction to militarism and military spending suggests that the blob’s monopoly might finally be collapsing.


Trump’s Sanctions on the ICC are an Assault on Justice & Security Everywhere

October 9, 2026 – In response to the Trump administration’s imposition of sanctions on the International Criminal Court as an institution, Center for International Policy President & CEO Nancy Okail issued the following statement:

“With today’s sanctions on the International Criminal Court itself, Donald Trump has moved from targeting the court’s officials to trying to strangle the institution outright. By cutting the court off from the banks, vendors and service providers it depends on, the administration is openly trying, in Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s own words, to cripple its ability to operate. 

“This is the broadest attack yet on the one permanent tribunal able to prosecute war crimes, genocide and other crimes against humanity. It continues Trump’s efforts to make America a pariah state, and it gives comfort to brutal dictators, aggressors and human rights abusers around the world. 

“It is no coincidence that this move comes just hours after Navi Pillay, a former ICC judge and former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize. Her award is a powerful affirmation of the value of multilateral institutions and the rule of law. It is also a well-deserved recognition of a career spent defending human rights and pursuing the prosecution of war crimes. Pillay has been relentlessly defamed by defenders of Israel’s conduct for leading the UN Commission of Inquiry that rightly found that genocide was being committed in Gaza.

“The Nobel Committee’s decision brings renewed attention to that finding and sends a strong message that it, and the people affected by it, cannot be pushed aside by political pressure. The Trump administration answered the same day with more pressure. As with its previous sanctions, the objective of attacking the court is to ensure absolute impunity for those who seek to act unrestrained by any law.

“This US assault on international law should be met with a strong response. States that are party to the Rome Statute should reaffirm and carry out their obligations to the court, including the consistent enforcement of its warrants and orders. The European Union, every one of whose members is a party to the court, should swiftly invoke the EU Blocking Statute to prohibit European companies and banks from complying with these sanctions and to shield the court, its staff and those who cooperate with it. Statements of support for the court are not enough.

“US Members of Congress should unequivocally condemn these actions by Trump, and commit to undo them legislatively, along with every previous round of sanctions on ICC officials. They should treat this attack on a judicial body and its officers just as they treat Trump’s efforts to destroy domestic institutions of justice. 

“Defending the legitimacy of the ICC is an inseparable part of the fight to protect the rule of law in the United States and around the world. Those who fail to firmly oppose this attack –or worse, support it – are only helping Trump and his authoritarian friends make the world less safe.”


25 Years After 9/11: Remembrance and Reckoning

September 11, 2026 – Center for International Policy President & CEO Nancy Okail issued the following statement marking 25 years since the September 11, 2001 attacks:

Today we honor the memory of the nearly 3,000 people murdered in New York, Washington, and Shanksville 25 years ago. We remember those lost, the first responders, and every family who has experienced loss and suffering because of that terrible day.

We also recognize a hard truth: America’s disastrous response to 9/11 has done tremendous harm to the world and to the United States. 

The War on Terror launched in 9/11’s wake contributed to at least 4.5 million deaths and displaced more than 38 million people. It conjured an enemy that could be anywhere and built an industry to fight it – made up of military contractors, surveillance agencies, and weapons makers working in concert with a well-funded machinery of fear. It spawned quid pro quo partnerships with governments that traded military and intelligence cooperation for U.S. assistance, weapons, and diplomatic cover, then used them for domestic repression, corruption, and state murder. Authoritarians from Brasília to Beijing were incentivized to brand dissidents and targeted minorities as “terrorists.”

The costs came home too. In addition to the loss of more than 7,000 U.S. service members in post-9/11 conflicts, about 1.8 million veterans of these wars live with a service-connected disability, and more than a third have PTSD. Muslim, Arab, and South Asian Americans have been surveilled, profiled, and deported. Battlefield tactics boomeranged back to our police departments and neighborhood streets. The xenophobic nativism the War on Terror fed, the emergency powers it put in place, and the disregard of inconvenient facts it normalized poisons our politics and threatens our very democracy. Today’s assaults on immigrants, elections and the rule of law are not a break from the post-9/11 era. They are its product – the result of decades of terrible decisions and misconceptions. 

While America spent an estimated $8 trillion on our “forever wars,” peer nations invested in health, housing, infrastructure, and education, and now outpace us in life expectancy and quality of life. Americans’ futures are less secure, not despite what we spent on war, but in large part because of it. This year’s illegal, unnecessary, and costly war on Iran shows that this lesson still has not been learned by those in power. 

Americans, and people around the world, deserve accountability for these failures. A genuine reckoning must begin by acknowledging the mistakes: military adventurism, torture, lawless detention, violation of international law and the betrayal of our own principles. It continues by ending support for foreign governments that brutalize civilians, restoring the rule of law at home and in our conduct abroad, and investing in social goods, infrastructure and the environment, rather than war. 

Honoring those we lost 25 years ago and in the wars that followed means finally prioritizing the human security that Americans and all people deserve.


Recommit to Restraint in U.S. Cluster Munitions Policy 

By Mina Nur Basmaci and John Ramming Chappell

When Admiral Brad Cooper, commander of U.S. Central Command, condemned Iran’s use of cluster munitions against Israel as “inherently indiscriminate,” he underscored a legal and moral critique long associated with these weapons — one that sits uneasily alongside the Pentagon’s own recent decision to purchase them.

On September 30, 2025, the Department of Defense quietly awarded an indefinite-quantity contract with a ceiling value of $829.1 million to Tomer, an Israeli-government-owned weapons company, for the manufacture, testing, and production of the 155mm High Explosive Advanced Submunition XM1208 projectile: a cluster munition. The contract was not publicly reported until February 2026 and represents the largest recorded weapons procurement by the Department of Defense from Israel.

Then, on December 5, 2025, the Army announced a market survey “to identify potential sources within the United States” for production of the XM1208 projectile, seeking responses from sources capable of consistently producing 30,000 cluster munitions per year. The stated purpose is to “broaden the target set, enhance lethality, and extend the reach of the current cannon platforms beyond the current…capability.”

These recent actions suggest the United States is recommitting to cluster munitions. Although it has not destroyed its existing stockpiles and has transferred cluster munitions to other countries, the U.S. has neither purchased nor itself used cluster munitions for almost two decades. Such a shift implicates international humanitarian law, breaks with longstanding policy and international consensus, and demands an according response from Congress.

Cluster Munitions and International Humanitarian Law

Cluster munitions are explosive weapons that disperse submunitions, or “bomblets,” over broad areas. The XM1208 cluster munition scatters nine submunitions that in turn explode and release around 1,200 tungsten steel fragments. These fragments have been found to disproportionately maim and kill children in Gaza. 

By design, cluster munitions are explosive weapons with wide area effects. They saturate broad zones rather than strike discrete targets, making them exceptionally difficult to direct with precision. In practice, their effects often extend far beyond intended military objectives, with devastating consequences for civilians. Cluster munitions are among the deadliest weapons for civilians, who accounted for 91% of recorded casualties from cluster munitions in 2025. 

Imitation cluster bombs hang inside the Cooperative Orthotic and Prosthetic Enterprise (COPE) centre in the Laos capital, Vientiane. (Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Australia)

The risks posed by cluster munitions persist long after active hostilities cease. Many submunitions fail to detonate as intended, with dud rates ranging from 2 to 40 percent depending on the system and conditions of use. These unexploded bomblets effectively become landmines, contaminating fields, roads, and residential areas. Their enduring presence renders land unusable, delays reconstruction, prolongs displacement, and poses acute risks to civilians — especially children. The small size of unexploded ordnance and, at times, their brightly colored casings or ribbons, make them particularly attractive to children who can mistake them for toys. Children accounted for 71% of deaths from cluster munition remnants in 2022 where age was recorded. 

International humanitarian law (IHL) imposes clear limits on the means and methods of warfare. Central among these is the principle of distinction, which requires parties to a conflict to distinguish between civilians and combatants and between civilian objects and military objectives. The principle reflects both customary international law and U.S. treaty obligations pursuant to the Geneva Conventions. Articles 51 and 52 of Additional Protocol I prohibit directing attacks against civilians and strictly limit lawful targets to objects that make an effective contribution to military action and whose destruction offers a definite military advantage.

Cluster munitions raise serious concerns with respect to distinction. Their effects are typically  indiscriminate when used in areas where civilians are present: they disperse submunitions over large areas and often leave behind unexploded ordnance that continues to threaten civilians long after the initial attack. This combination makes it exceedingly difficult—if not impossible in many contexts—to ensure compliance with the rule of distinction. It was this concern that led Adm. Cooper to characterize cluster munitions as “inherently indiscriminate.”

Even where a legitimate military objective is present, the principle of proportionality further constrains attacks. Proportionality does not prohibit incidental civilian harm outright, but it forbids attacks in which the expected civilian harm would be excessive in relation to the anticipated, concrete and direct military advantage. The use of cluster munitions, especially in densely populated areas, complicates compliance as their wide-area effects and high dud rates create foreseeable risks of significant civilian harm both immediately and over time. Indeed, leading human rights organizations regard the use of cluster munitions in a populated area as a violation of IHL.

Experience bears this out. Laos is the most heavily bombed country in the world: during the Vietnam War in the 1960s and 1970s, it endured intense aerial bombardment by the U.S. More than two million tons of cluster munitions were dropped on the country. Roughly one-third failed to detonate on impact, leaving about 30% of Laos still contaminated with unexploded ordnance more than 50 years later. In Lebanon, Israeli cluster munitions have contaminated some of the country’s poorest regions. Dropped in the final 72 hours of Israel’s 2006 war with Hezbollah, more than 4 million unexploded submunitions continue to kill and maim Lebanese civilians, particularly children, and have caused the displacement of some 200,000 people. Today, Russian forces have consistently deployed cluster munitions in densely populated areas in Ukraine. Ukrainian forces have also deployed cluster munitions supplied by the U.S., discussed below. The 2025 Cluster Munition Monitor reported over 1,200 civilian deaths and injuries from cluster munitions across Ukraine since the full-scale invasion began. 

In light of the inherent civilian harm risks that cluster munitions pose, 111 countries have ratified the Convention on Cluster Munitions (CCM), which bans their use, development, production, acquisition, stockpiling, and transfer. The United States—alongside Israel, Russia, Ukraine, and China—is not a party to the Convention. Yet before recent developments, the United States recognized the risks of cluster munitions and committed to policies and soft-law frameworks to constrain their use. 

U.S. Policy Regarding Cluster Munitions 

Historically, the United States has acknowledged the humanitarian risks associated with cluster munitions and taken steps — albeit short of a complete ban — to mitigate them. The U.S. has been a global leader in funding the clearance of unexploded ordnance, contributing more than $2.8 billion since 1993 to programs in over 100 countries. It has also endorsed the Political Declaration on Strengthening the Protection of Civilians from the Humanitarian Consequences of Explosive Weapons in Populated Areas (EWIPA), committing to avoid the use of such weapons in populated areas and to improve civilian harm mitigation and response.

 Disposal of cluster bomblets from Russian cruise missile in Kirovohrad Oblast of Ukraine.

The United States has not used cluster munitions in combat since 2003, aside from a single reported strike in Yemen in 2009, and no U.S. company currently produces them. A 2008 Department of Defense directive phased out the use and transfer of cluster munitions with high failure rates. And a longstanding U.S. law restricts the export of cluster munitions with a failure rate above one percent and requires specification that the cluster munitions will not be used against civilians, subject to only an override by the President in exceptional circumstances. Against this backdrop, renewed procurement marks a notable departure from prior U.S. practice and from the broader trajectory of international norm crystallization.

At the same time, U.S. policy has grown increasingly inconsistent. The longstanding 2008 policy (adopted under George W. Bush in 2008 and continued by Barack Obama) was significantly relaxed in 2017 by President Trump, allowing continued use of existing stockpiles and transfer to replenish munitions. President Biden also waived the appropriations restriction at least seven times to enable the transfer of cluster munitions to Ukraine, drawing bipartisan criticism from Congress, other States, and the United Nations.

While these actions represent concerning backsliding in practices around stockpiling and transfer, the U.S. purchasing and seeking to produce cluster munitions for its own operations marks a troubling step toward renewed use.

Where Is Congress?

This episode reflects a broader pattern whereby the Executive branch plays a leading role in shaping—and at times weakening—international norms governing the conduct of war, often with limited legislative input despite relevant constitutional and Congressional authority. 

Congress has several tools to respond to this procurement and to reassert its constitutional role and oversight function, especially with respect to the “power of the purse.” Other relevant constitutional authorities include Congress’ power to “make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and naval Forces” and to “define and punish… Offenses against the Law of Nations.” As far as transfers are concerned, the Foreign Commerce Clause assigns to Congress the authority to regulate exports from the United States. 

When it comes to cluster munitions, Congress can convene hearings and oversight inquiries. It may also impose conditions through the annual National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) or appropriations legislation, which may include requirements for reporting or limitations on the use and transfer of cluster munitions. Rep. Sara Jacobs (CA-51) has led amendments to the NDAA aiming to restrict cluster munitions transfers in recent years. 

In exercising its authorities, Congress should focus on increasing transparency around the rationale and implications of cluster munition procurement and use, and determine how the Department of Defense is assessing compliance with international humanitarian law and our commitments under the EWIPA framework. It should also seek information on stockpile management, ascertain the dud rates of cluster munitions in U.S. possession, and exercise scrutiny over further entrenching a partnership with Israel, which is credibly accused of gross human rights violations. Irrespective of passage, these measures serve important record-building interests and reinforce Congress’ authority in this space. 

Absent meaningful congressional engagement, this procurement risks further enabling an Executive branch that has undermined and politicized international legal norms.

Consequences far beyond the battlefield

Taken together, the Department of Defense’s recent procurement and market survey represents a clear regression from prior U.S. policy commitments and normative leadership and undermines broader international efforts to protect civilians. Specifically, the policy shift risks alienating key NATO allies, many of whom are legally bound under the CCM. By moving in a direction that diverges from allies’ legal obligations and political commitments, the United States may introduce friction within alliance coordination and operations and weaken its credibility and role. For example, when the U.S. transferred cluster munitions to Ukraine via Germany,  Germany violated its obligations under the CCM to not allow transshipment of cluster munitions.

More broadly, the move contributes to an erosion of the emerging norm against cluster munition use. Norms of restraint are sustained not only through formal legal obligations but through consistent practice. When leading military powers signal renewed reliance on controversial weapons, it lowers the political and reputational costs for others to do the same. Lithuania’s 2025 withdrawal from the CCM—citing security concerns related to Russia—illustrates how quickly such norms can come under pressure absent a robust, mutually accountable, shared-values based approach rooted in respect for international humanitarian law.

Hold public hearings requiring the Pentagon and White House to explain the legal, strategic, and humanitarian rationale for procuring cluster munitions and restarting domestic production.
Condition, limit, or prohibit funding for the procurement, production, transfer, or use of cluster munitions through the NDAA.
Require comprehensive reporting and consistent monitoring from the Pentagon on stockpile levels, dud rates, procurement plans, use, and compliance with international humanitarian law.
Demand that congressional oversight and policymaking reflect the documented long-term humanitarian consequences of these weapons.
Support civil society, experts, survivors, and communities affected by cluster munitions and ensure policy reflects lessons from past use and accounts for the enduring risk cluster munitions pose to civilians.

Concerning also is the brazen inconsistency in how cluster munitions are regarded. This article has already mentioned Admiral Cooper’s comments concerning the legality of Iran’s use of cluster munitions against Israel. Similarly, States have widely condemned Russia’s use of cluster munitions against Ukraine. The U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations, Linda Thomas-Greenfield, has said to Russia that cluster munitions “have no place on the battlefield.” Yet the U.S. supplied cluster munitions to Ukraine, which have been deployed on the front lines, and it is now pursuing further procurement apparently for its own use. This contradiction risks undermining the credibility of legal norms and invites accusations of selective enforcement and lawfare. A consistent application of principles is essential—not only for maintaining legitimacy, but for ensuring the strongest possible protection of civilians in conflict.

Perilous next steps

Ultimately, the Department of Defense’s recent purchase and market survey is a quiet deal with loud consequences. It signals a potential renewed reliance by the U.S. on a weapons type widely regarded as among the most harmful to civilians, and risks deepening fractures with allies and weakening emerging norms designed to protect civilian populations. And when America sneezes, the world catches a cold; these actions may encourage similar backsliding by other countries.

Most importantly, the decision carries human consequences that extend far beyond the battlefield. Long after conflicts end, unexploded submunitions remain embedded in fields, villages, and cities, continuing to injure and kill civilians, especially children. 

It is too early to know whether and how the U.S. will put its procurement to use. But to maintain the norm against the use, transfer, and stockpiling of cluster munitions, States, civil society, and Congress must use their influence to oppose and scrutinize U.S. actions and enforce the norm. 

Mina Nur Basmaci is a former Advocacy & Legal Fellow at Center for Civilians in Conflict (CIVIC). John Ramming Chappell is an Advocacy & Legal Advisor at Center for Civilians in Conflict (CIVIC).


Congress and Other US Officials Must Act to Counter Trump’s Genocidal Threats against the Iranian People

April 7, 2026 – Center for International Policy President & CEO Nancy Okail issued the following statement in response to President Trump’s escalating threats against the Iranian people:

“President Trump’s genocidal threats against Iran, including that “a whole civilization may die tonight,” shows he has lost control of an illegal and unnecessary war that he recklessly started. His pledge to launch a major assault specifically targeting civilian infrastructure across Iran is an announcement of an intent to commit wholesale war crimes.

“Partner countries, cabinet officials and Congress must do everything in their power to prevent this slaughter and further civilian deaths, regional escalation and global economic turmoil.

“U.S. allies who have not already done so should immediately prohibit the U.S. military from using their territory, including their airspace, in connection with further attacks on Iran. Trump administration officials, as well as commanders in the U.S. Armed Forces, should uphold their oaths by refusing to carry out unlawful orders issued by the president or others on his behalf.

“Congress should immediately reconvene to pass a War Powers Resolution disengaging U.S. Armed Forces from hostilities against Iran. Lawmakers should also make clear that they will not support any supplemental appropriation whatsoever to fund this unauthorized war.

“It should also be made clear that there must be accountability for those who started this illegal war of choice and committed war crimes in its prosecution. The failure to hold decisionmakers accountable for the U.S. invasion of Iraq and enabling Israel’s genocide in Gaza has led to this extremely dangerous moment in which a lawless president is threatening an entire people with destruction. Upholding the rule of law and basic decency requires that this illegal war end and those responsible for it face justice.”



Bringing Democratic Accountability To Remote Weapons

Warfare is increasingly conducted through sensors, networks, and remote platforms that keep their human operators far from danger. This distance has strategic, political, and ethical consequences that are only beginning to be understood. Erik Lin-Greenberg’s The Remote Revolution offers the clearest account to date of how uninhabited systems reshape leader behavior, crisis dynamics, and modern statecraft. His findings invite a second question. How should democracies design institutions that prevent unnecessary harm before it occurs and preserve accountability when conflict becomes remote?

Lin-Greenberg’s central insight is that remote systems introduce a predictable shift in how states initiate and manage the use of force. When leaders can act without risking their own personnel, their behavior changes. He writes that reduced risks “can lower the threshold for dispatching forces, creating a moral hazard that enables decision makers to launch military operations during interstate disputes when their state arsenals include drones.”1 His evidence spans wargames, surveys, and archival case studies. Participants accepted higher escalatory risk when uninhabited assets were involved. During the Cold War, both superpowers relied on remote reconnaissance for missions that would have been politically untenable with crews aboard. When Iran shot down a US Global Hawk drone in 2019, the absence of American casualties made it politically easier to absorb the loss and step back from escalation. These examples illustrate how distance alters strategic judgment, reducing both the barriers to initiation and, at times, the pressure to retaliate.

Lower risk expands what Lin-Greenberg calls the “menu of options.”2 Remote systems enable actions that fall between inaction and major escalation, including reconnaissance, limited strikes, and coercive signals that impose costs without creating public alarm. Azerbaijan’s reliance on drones in the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war illustrates how remote tools expand operational choice while managing political exposure. Israel’s routine use of drones in cross-border operations against regional adversaries demonstrates how leaders create intermediate space between symbolic warning and high-intensity response. In episodes involving Syria and Hezbollah, remote systems have enabled calibrated signaling without the immediate risks associated with crewed aircraft.

Clankers and Casualties

One of Lin-Greenberg’s most distinctive findings concerns how states respond to attacks on uninhabited systems. Rivals often treat drone shootdowns differently from incidents involving inhabited aircraft. These losses rarely generate public pressure for retaliation. Decision-makers frequently see shooting down a drone as a low-risk signal of dissatisfaction.3 Cold War episodes show that remote-platform losses were treated as manageable setbacks rather than triggers for escalation.4 Israeli cases confirm similar restraint. These dynamics produce what Lin-Greenberg describes as “more but milder conflicts.”5 Remote systems do not eliminate escalation. They change its form, making crises more frequent but less likely to cross into major interstate war.

Public opinion plays a central role in this transformation. Lin-Greenberg notes that reduced risk “mitigates the political obstacles often associated with sending troops into harm’s way.”6 When political costs fall, strategic discretion expands. Drone campaigns in US counterterrorism operations illustrate this pattern. Casualty aversion remains a constant in democratic politics. Remote technology changes how leaders weigh those incentives.

For policymakers grappling with the expanding role of autonomous and remote systems, The Remote Revolution provides a rigorous and indispensable foundation.

Lin-Greenberg’s contribution is descriptive and theoretical. He explains how remote systems alter incentives and behavior. The next task is institutional. Democracies must translate this knowledge into preventive design. Recent analysis in the International Policy Journal has argued that compliance with the laws of war should be engineered directly into autonomous and remote systems. Embedding discrimination and proportionality requirements is a start. But engineering norms into code is insufficient without reforming the institutions that authorize and oversee lethal force.

Oversight and Operations

Oversight becomes more complex when remote operations move across statutory authorities. Military operations conducted under Title 10 are subject to armed services oversight and reporting requirements. Covert actions conducted under Title 50 are reported to intelligence committees and often operate under tighter secrecy. The migration of drone strikes between these frameworks during the post-9/11 era demonstrated how lethal authority can shift between oversight regimes with different transparency standards. Designing for prevention requires harmonizing expectations across authorities so that distance cannot exploit jurisdictional gaps.

Recent allegations of unlawful airstrikes against civilian vessels underscore the institutional stakes. When force is projected at distance against targets that are difficult for the public to visualize or verify, the risk is not only civilian harm but erosion of democratic accountability. The problem is structural rather than partisan. Any administration operating with remote tools faces incentives to lower political friction. The question is whether institutions are strong enough to resist that pressure.

A durable institutional response requires at least four changes:

  1. Congress should require sunset provisions for semiautonomous lethal authorities, mandating explicit reauthorization every two years. This would prevent normalization of delegated force.
  2. Agencies conducting lethal operations should submit public civilian harm prevention certifications before deploying new remote or AI-enabled systems, reviewed by an independent inspector general.
  3. Lawmakers should codify a named human decision authority requirement for every lethal action conducted through remote or autonomous systems, with documented reasoning preserved for review.
  4. Congress should establish automatic reporting triggers for the use of force against civilian vessels or non-state maritime actors, requiring public disclosure within a fixed timeframe.

These reforms do not prohibit remote warfare. They restore friction where political cost has diminished.

Designing for prevention also requires cultural change. Officers and analysts should be rewarded for surfacing uncertainty and slowing operations when civilian risk is ambiguous. Near-miss reporting should be protected from reprisal. Restraint must be treated as competence rather than hesitation.

Remote technologies are diffusing rapidly across state and non-state actors, normalizing distance in both surveillance and strike capabilities.7 The incentives Lin-Greenberg identifies are unlikely to remain confined to major powers. That makes institutional design more urgent, not less.

Distance changes what leaders see and what the public feels. Without institutional reform, it will erode the accountability that gives democratic uses of force their legitimacy. Democracies must build systems that prevent unnecessary harm, maintain human judgment at the center of lethal authority, and preserve moral clarity even when conflict unfolds beyond the horizon of public view. Remote systems may change the character of war. Deliberate design must determine how democracies respond.

Lucas F. Schleusener is a Term Member of the Council on Foreign Relations. You can follow him on Bluesky at @lfschleusener.bsky.social.


1 Erik Lin-Greenberg, The Remote Revolution (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2025), 5.
2 Lin-Greenberg, The Remote Revolution, 25.
3 Ibid., 33.
4 Ibid., 108.
5  Lin-Greenberg, The Remote Revolution, 5.
6 Ibid.
7  See, for example, Faine Greenwood’s reporting and analysis on the global diffusion of drone technologies and the regulatory lag surrounding remote systems.

From the Sahel to Saint Paul, Curtailing Security Force Abuse Prevents Violence

In January, Americans became immediately and tragically familiar with the spectacle of masked and armed agents of Federal security forces shooting civilians in broad daylight. The horrific violence from Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) against people in Minnesota, particularly the killings of protestors Renee Good and Alex Pretti, match the threat to everyday society seen in places abroad where security forces operate with reckless impunity. Immediate deescalation is necessary in Minneapolis, along with a commitment to avoid similar violence in other cities, but we must acknowledge that it is unlikely this administration will end their campaign to remove undocumented immigrants through seemingly any means. The systemic security force abuse that is accompanying ICE’s presence across American cities and hidden in detention centers will have lasting damage, particularly on already vulnerable immigrant communities and requires comprehensive prevention efforts by civil society and local government. 

This kind of violence is not new, even in the United States where police abuse has resulted in numerous deaths, though its deliberate provocation by a Presidency against the people of a US state is unique. In the past protecting civilians from such violence was seen as a crucial part of US foreign policy, as part of a holistic effort to combat the conditions that foster violent extremism.

I have spent my career designing and managing conflict prevention, counterterrorism and security assistance policy and programs in Africa. I am not the first to remark on the striking similarities occurring on American streets with what I witnessed in multiple authoritarian African countries. I’ve sat in traffic, protected by diplomatic plates, eyes down and afraid to truly look, as police officers beat a man who was refusing, or couldn’t pay a bribe. I’ve designed security assistance programs across the Sahel that have been canceled due to massive military attacks against unarmed civilians in the name of counterterrorism. I’ve interviewed young people who defected from Boko Haram to learn why they joined, and personal or family abuse by security officials was often a primary reason. 

Strengthen hyper-local resilience networks
Rebuild trust in security forces through community-engaged policing at the state and local level
Ensure a gender-sensitive approach
Provide psychosocial support and counseling to those that have suffered or witnessed security force abuses

I live in Washington DC, one of the first cities to be targeted by the Trump administration’s campaign to round up immigrants without regard for accepted standards of engagement. Like many in the community who pulled together through a patchwork system of signal chats, I drove kids to school who no longer felt comfortable walking or taking the metro. On our drives, we frequently witnessed masked agents pulling people, mostly men, from their cars and violently pressing them against the doors or shoving them to the ground, instantly handcuffed behind their back. Sometimes we drove past in silence, avoiding eye contact because it was too difficult. Other times they chatted in Spanish, identifying friends who lived in nearby buildings and texting them to make sure they knew to stay home. One day, the dreaded news came through: one of their fathers had been abducted on the street on his way to work. After being transferred from one detention facility to another, he told his family that the conditions were so terrible that he felt he had no choice but to self deport. 

Although media attention is focused intently on Minneapolis now, ICE is still present in Washington and many other cities around the country, and their violent tactics have become emboldened and sanctioned by political officials. In fact, rather than simply being a tactic, ICE violence has become a policy, and a means to promote and enforce power. 

Decades of research in Africa has shown that lack of trust in government, security force impunity, and general perception of marginalization are factors that can lead to recruitment by violent extremist organizations, especially when triggered by a “tipping point” event such as violent abuse by security forces. While there is no indication of increased violence among communities targeted by ICE, American civil society, and eventually the American government, should be attentive to these risks and take steps to prevent increased marginalization and risk of violent non-state groups forming in response to the abuses they have faced. 

As the large-scale public response in Minneapolis and micro-level networks to protect and support neighbors across the country have shown, communities are resilient in the face of state sponsored violence. I’ve seen this personally through hundreds of community-based organizations I’ve worked with across Africa that have developed with limited resources to protect their people who face violence from both the government and non-state armed groups. 

Federally sanctioned security force violence has harmed a sacred social contract between Americans and the government, but there are ways to prevent longer term damage. Although the context between the African countries where I have worked and the United States is very different, international experience and evidence suggest that states, cities and civil society could focus on the following actions to mitigate the risks of continued state violence and repression:

  1. Strengthen hyper-local resilience networks: Protection and support that occurs closest to home such as Parent Teacher Associations (PTAs), neighborhood committees, or churches/houses of worship can provide a sense of belonging that reduces real or perceived marginalization. These frontline groups may be able to help develop strategies and capacities to resist violence. Many of these networks exist organically but can be strengthened with external financial or organizational support, however it’s important not to overwhelm their authenticity. 
  2. Rebuild trust in security forces through community-engaged policing at the state and local level: This approach is not new to the American context where some law enforcement entities have spent decades building relationships and trust within immigrant communities. Rebuilding or developing positive relationships that effectively address non-immigration related crime will require redoubling these efforts and focusing on transparency and independence from immigration enforcement. Lessons can be drawn from Kenya, for example, where there has been significant challenges of police misconduct and political interference. 
  3. Ensure a gender-sensitive approach: Although many of the people impacted directly by ICE’s violence are adult men, women’s lives are also changed particularly if they must take on additional roles to support their family financially to compensate for the loss of one income if a spouse is detained or deported. A gender sensitive approach should also consider the impact on boys and young men, whose role in the family and society may also be shifting. 
  4. Provide psychosocial support and counseling to those that have suffered or witnessed security force abuses: Given the risk that security force abuses can be a tipping point towards violence, it is critical to address this trauma early and provide ongoing counseling particularly for youth. Psychosocial support has been identified as a critical aspect of peacebuilding, reintegration of former fighters, and post conflict reconstruction following many types of violent conflict in Africa.

In the near term, these actions will fall to civil society, state and local government, and private citizens. The Trump administration has decimated many federal government services that address community violence prevention and detection domestically and abroad in the Departments of Homeland Security (DHS) Justice, and State, as well as the FBI, including funding for NGOs. But beyond that, as was the case in many other countries I have worked in, the use of sanctioned state sponsored violence is intentional. As opposed to many countries, where political leadership acknowledges the need to address systemic security force abuses but fails to control it in practice, in the United States, such abuse continues to be promoted as acceptable. The tragic deaths of Renee Good and Alex Pretti, as well as the deaths of at least 53 people held in detention by DHS, are a direct result of the consistent sanctioned violence by security forces. This violence continues around the country, in neighborhoods where national media has gathered to witness it and in others where the harm is documented only by bystanders, and it is causing both short- and long-term damage to this country, and requires a holistic response. 

Margot Shorey is an expert on counterterrorism and conflict prevention and previously served in the Department of State Bureaus of African Affairs and Conflict and Stabilization Operations.